| YEAR | NAME | SCHOOL |
| 1981 | Jim Durant | Payson |
| 1982 | Harry Burchell | Bonneville |
| 1983 | Dick Hill | Provo |
| 1984 | Jim Hill | Davis District |
| 1985 | Mel Roberts | Tooele |
| 1986 | Darold Simmons | Taylorsville |
| 1987 | Lee Dickemore | Weber |
| 1988 | Lee Dickemore | Weber |
| 1989 | Gordon Peterson | Box Elder |
| 1990 | Larry Shumway | Pine View |
| 1991 | Elliot Jordan | Springville |
| 1992 | Dave Nordquist, CAA | Ogden |
| 1993 | Evan Excell, CAA | Ben Lomond |
| 1994 | Fred Crawford, CAA | Granite District |
| 1995 | Joel Gardner, CAA | Mountain View |
| 1996 | Paul Dart | Tooele |
| 1997 | Tim Braithwaite | Spanish Fork |
| 1998 | Lou Andrus | Lehi |
| 1999 | Marc Hunter, CMAA | Jordan |
| 2000 | Ferril Heaton | Valley |
| 2001 | Dan Cowan, CMAA | West Jordan |
| 2002 | Ferril Heaton | Valley |
| 2003 | Craig Gladwell, CAA | Lehi |
| 2004 | Dan Leatherwood, CAA | Taylorsville |
| 2005 | Mick Fieldsted, CAA | Altamont |
| 2006 | Kendra Tomsic, CAA | Rowland Hall/St. Marks |
| 2007 | John Dowell, CAA | Monticello |
| 2008 | Steve Marsing, CAA | Skyline |
| 2009 | Bud Campbell, CAA | Retired |
| 2010 | Richard Barton, CMAA | Richfield |
| 2011 | Alana Benson, CAA | Parowan |
| 2012 | Gordon Hinckley, CMAA | Riverton |
| 2013 | Ronald Dolphin, CAA | Grand County |
| 2014 | Ren Hoopes, CAA | Morgan |
| 2015 | Clayton Carter, CMAA | Wendover |
| 2016 | Ted Petersen, CAA | Weber |
| 2017 | David Boyack, CAA | Maple Mountain |
| 2018 | Jamie Sheetz, CAA | Park City |
| 2019 | Mike Hunter, CAA | Timpview |
| 2020 | Trever Wilson, CMAA | Stansbury |
| 2021 | Ryan Grunig, CAA | Sky View |
| 2022 | Michael O’Connor, CMAA | Westlake |
| 2023 | Catham Beer, CMAA | Tooele |
| 2024 | Everett Kelepolo, CMAA | Nebo |